Skip to content
ContentLora

    Tip: press / anywhere to search.

    Analysis

    Should the US resume nuclear testing? The debate explained

    The United States has observed a voluntary moratorium on nuclear explosive testing since 1992, while keeping the ability to resume at the Nevada National Security Site.[1] In October and November 2025 President Trump made statements suggesting the United States could restart testing "on an equal basis" with other countries; as of December 2025 the Congressional Research Service said it was unclear what policy change, if any, would follow.[2][3] Supporters of testing cite negotiating leverage and Chinese and Russian activity; opponents warn it could prompt other states to test and help rivals catch up.[4][5]

    Editor reviewedStrict sourcingUpdated Analysis23 claims · 100% primaryDefense and security, World affairs, Tech policy
    Show:

    This analysis keeps sourced facts apart from interpretation. It attributes each argument to the people or governments that made it, mostly as summarised by the Congressional Research Service. It takes no position on whether the United States should test. It covers events up to the FY2027 budget hearings in mid-2026; no US explosive test had been reported in the sources used.

    What happened

    The United States has observed a voluntary moratorium on nuclear explosive testing since 1992, while keeping the ability to resume tests at the Nevada National Security Site.[1] In October and November 2025, President Trump made statements suggesting that the United States could restart testing.[2] US officials later described this as an instruction to the Pentagon to start testing “on an equal basis”.[6] President Trump’s announcement said the United States would test on an equal basis with other countries.[3]

    As of December 2025, the Congressional Research Service (CRS) said it was unclear what change of policy, if any, would follow.[2] In April and May 2026 hearings on the nuclear weapons budget, some members of Congress sought details on US testing policy. The Senate Armed Services Committee’s report on the FY2027 defense bill directs the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) to brief the defense committees on nuclear explosive test readiness.[7]

    The rules on testing

    • Past testing: by its own count, the United States conducted 1,054 explosive nuclear tests from 1945 to 1992. The Nevada site hosted 928 of them, including 100 in the atmosphere.[8]
    • Treaties in force: since 1963 the Limited Test Ban Treaty has barred US test explosions in the atmosphere, outer space and under water. The 1974 Threshold Test Ban Treaty bars underground tests above 150 kilotons.[9]
    • US law: the 1992 Hatfield-Exon-Mitchell Amendment bars underground tests after 30 September 1996 unless a foreign state tests after that date. Several foreign states have tested since 1996.[10]
    • The test-ban treaty: President Clinton signed the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) and sent it to the Senate in 1997. The Senate rejected it on 13 October 1999, by 48 votes to 51 with one present.[11] The treaty enters into force only once 44 listed states have ratified it.[12] As of December 2025, 187 states had signed and 178 had ratified. Russia revoked its ratification in November 2023, and India, Pakistan and North Korea have tested since 1996.[13]
    • Zero yield: the CTBT’s standard rules out any test that produces a self-sustaining, supercritical chain reaction. Neither the treaty nor the US moratorium bars subcritical experiments, which produce no nuclear yield.[14]

    For more on the treaties, see arms control explained. For the physics of a chain reaction, see how nuclear weapons work.

    How the US keeps weapons working without tests

    Since 1993 the United States has relied on Science-Based Stockpile Stewardship. Under it, NNSA runs subcritical experiments in Nevada and uses computer modelling and other tools to keep the stockpile reliable without nuclear tests.[15] As of May 2024 the United States had carried out 34 subcritical experiments since the moratorium began. In 2023 NNSA officials said they aimed to reach three a year by the end of the decade.[16] In an August 2024 video, the then-NNSA Administrator said the United States has “no technical reasons” to conduct nuclear tests.[17]

    Readiness. The goal, set in 1993, is to be able to resume testing within 24 to 36 months of a presidential decision. A 2022 national security memorandum set an expectation of being ready for an underground test within 36 months.[18] A 2012 National Academies study found that the time needed depends more on environmental, health and safety rules than on technical needs. NNSA planning documents note that the President can declare a national emergency and waive those restrictions.[19] NNSA has not funded test readiness as a separate program since FY2010. Instead, the work is paid for through other weapons programs.[20]

    The arguments

    For testing, or for being ready to test. CRS summarises several arguments. In 2020, some advocates of a test said it could help in negotiations on a three-way arms deal. A former Trump administration official argued in 2024 for testing new weapons to keep superiority over the combined Chinese and Russian stockpiles. Another urged NNSA to move to immediate test readiness.[4]

    Supporters also point to rivals’ conduct. Since 2019, State Department compliance reports have said Russia conducted nuclear weapons-related experiments with greater than zero yield. US statements also describe China expanding its testing capacity.[21]

    Against testing. Opponents argue that a US test could lead other nuclear states to resume testing and fuel arms races. Former Los Alamos director Siegfried Hecker argued that it would let Russia and China catch up, since the United States has run far more tests and has better computing tools. Former Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz said testing was “not justified by science or military necessity”.[5] Russian President Vladimir Putin said in October 2025 that if others test, Russia “will respond in kind”.[22]

    Much of the argument turns on what “testing” means. A full explosive test would end a moratorium in place since 1992. More subcritical experiments or faster test readiness would keep within the zero-yield standard that the United States, the UK and France follow.[14][3] The two sides also read the same facts differently. Supporters see US claims about Russian and Chinese activity as a reason to act. Opponents see the large US lead in past test data as a reason not to give rivals cover to test.[21][5]

    For the wider state of arms control after New START expired in February 2026, see the debate after New START. For warhead counts by country, see nuclear arsenals by country.

    Competing views

    Resume testing or get ready to

    Some former Trump administration officials and others argued that testing new weapons would keep the United States ahead of the combined Chinese and Russian stockpiles, that a test could help in arms talks, and that NNSA should move to immediate test readiness. US statements question whether Russia and China keep to the zero-yield standard.[4][21]

    Keep the moratorium

    Opponents argue resumed testing could lead other nuclear states to test and fuel arms races, and would help Russia and China, which have tested far less, catch up. Former Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz said testing was not justified by science or military necessity, and NNSA's then-head said in 2024 there were no technical reasons to test.[5][22][17]

    Developing in World & Policy

    Questions readers ask

    When did the United States last test a nuclear weapon?

    In 1992. The United States has kept a voluntary moratorium on nuclear explosive testing since then, after conducting 1,054 explosive tests from 1945, 928 of them at the Nevada test site.[1][8]

    What did President Trump say about nuclear testing?

    In October and November 2025 he made statements suggesting the United States could restart testing, saying it would test 'on an equal basis' with other countries. In December 2025 CRS said it was unclear what change of policy, if any, would follow.[2][3][6]

    Is nuclear testing illegal for the United States?

    Treaties already bar US tests in the atmosphere, space and under water, and underground tests above 150 kilotons. A 1992 law bars underground tests after September 1996 unless a foreign state tests, and several have. The Senate rejected the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty in 1999, and the treaty has not entered into force.[9][10][11][12][23]

    How quickly could the United States test?

    The goal since 1993 has been 24 to 36 months after a presidential decision; a 2022 memorandum set an expectation of 36 months for an underground test. Environmental, health and safety rules drive much of that time, though a president can declare a national emergency and waive them.[18][19]

    What are subcritical experiments?

    Experiments that produce no nuclear yield, which neither the test-ban treaty nor the US moratorium prohibits. The United States had conducted 34 since 1992 as of May 2024 and plans to reach three a year by the end of the decade.[14][16]

    Are Russia and China testing?

    US compliance reports have said since 2019 that Russia conducted nuclear weapons-related experiments with greater than zero yield, and US statements describe China expanding its testing capacity. US statements question whether either keeps to the zero-yield standard that the UK and France follow.[21][3]

    Sources

    · 23 claims from 4 publishers

    Each numbered claim is a statement we checked against the sources listed with it. Tap a number in the text to see its sources in place.

    1. [1]

      The United States has observed a voluntary moratorium on nuclear explosive testing since 1992, while keeping the ability to resume tests at the Nevada National Security Site. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    2. [2]

      CRS says President Trump made statements in October and November 2025 suggesting the United States could restart nuclear testing, and that as of December 2025 it was unclear what policy change, if any, would follow. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    3. [3]

      President Trump's announcement said the United States would test 'on an equal basis' with other countries; CRS notes that the UK and France keep to a zero-yield testing standard, while US official statements question whether Russia and China keep to theirs. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    4. [4]

      CRS summarises arguments made for testing: some said in 2020 that a test could help in negotiations, a former Trump administration official argued in 2024 for testing new weapons to keep superiority over Chinese and Russian stockpiles, and another urged immediate test readiness. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    5. [5]

      CRS summarises arguments against: opponents say resumed testing could prompt other states to test and fuel arms races; former Los Alamos director Siegfried Hecker argued it would let Russia and China catch up; and former Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz said it was not justified by science or military necessity. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    6. [6]

      In autumn 2025 President Trump instructed the Pentagon to start testing US nuclear weapons 'on an equal basis'. confirmedas of 2026-02-07

    7. [7]

      In April and May 2026 hearings on NNSA's FY2027 budget, some members of Congress sought details on US policy on nuclear testing, and the Senate Armed Services Committee's FY2027 defense bill report directs NNSA to brief the defense committees on nuclear explosive test readiness. confirmedas of 2026-07-14

    8. [8]

      By its own count, the United States conducted 1,054 explosive nuclear tests between 1945 and 1992; the Nevada site hosted 928 of them, including 100 atmospheric tests. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    9. [9]

      The United States has been party since 1963 to the Limited Test Ban Treaty, which bars test explosions in the atmosphere, outer space and under water, and to the 1974 Threshold Test Ban Treaty, which bars underground tests above 150 kilotons. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    10. [10]

      A 1992 law, the Hatfield-Exon-Mitchell Amendment, set a temporary US moratorium on underground testing and barred tests after 30 September 1996 unless a foreign state tested after that date; several foreign states have tested since 1996. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    11. [11]

      President Clinton signed the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty and sent it to the Senate in 1997; the Senate rejected it on 13 October 1999 by 48 votes for to 51 against, with 1 present. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    12. [12]

      The Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty opened for signature in September 1996 and enters into force only after all 44 states listed in its Annex 2 have ratified it. confirmedas of 2026-11-07

    13. [13]

      As of December 2025, 187 states had signed the CTBT and 178 had ratified it; Russia revoked its ratification in November 2023, and India, Pakistan and North Korea have carried out explosive tests since the treaty opened for signature. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    14. [14]

      The CTBT's zero-yield standard rules out any test producing a self-sustaining, supercritical chain reaction; neither the treaty nor the US moratorium bars subcritical experiments that produce no nuclear yield. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    15. [15]

      Since 1993 the United States has relied on the Science-Based Stockpile Stewardship program, under which NNSA uses subcritical experiments and computing to maintain the arsenal without nuclear tests. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    16. [16]

      The United States had carried out 34 subcritical experiments since the 1992 moratorium as of May 2024, and NNSA officials said in 2023 they aimed for three a year by the end of the decade. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    17. [17]

      In an August 2024 video, the then-NNSA Administrator said the United States has 'no technical reasons' to conduct nuclear tests. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    18. [18]

      The United States aims to be able to resume testing within 24 to 36 months of a presidential decision, a goal set in 1993; a 2022 national security memorandum set an expectation of readiness for an underground test within 36 months. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    19. [19]

      A 2012 National Academies study found that the time needed to resume underground testing depends more on environmental, health and safety rules than on technical requirements; NNSA plans note that the President can declare a national emergency and waive those restrictions. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    20. [20]

      NNSA has not funded nuclear test readiness as a separate program since FY2010; readiness work is paid for through other Weapons Activities programs, for which NNSA requested $4.2 billion for research, technology and engineering in FY2026. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    21. [21]

      Since 2019 the State Department's compliance report has said Russia conducted nuclear weapons-related experiments with greater than zero yield, and US statements describe China expanding its nuclear testing capacity. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    22. [22]

      Russian President Vladimir Putin said in October 2025 that if others conduct tests, Russia will respond in kind. confirmedas of 2025-12-16

    23. [23]

      UNODA lists nine Annex 2 states that have not ratified the CTBT: China, North Korea, Egypt, India, Iran, Israel, Pakistan, Russia and the United States. confirmedas of 2026-11-07

    Revision history (1)
    1. Page created.

    Created Nov 14, 2026. Last reviewed by an editor on Nov 15, 2026. Next scheduled review: May 14, 2027.

    Cite this page

    "Should the US resume nuclear testing? The debate explained." ContentLora, updated Nov 14, 2026. https://contentlora.com/analysis/us-nuclear-testing-debate

    Spotted an error? Suggest a correction or emailcorrections@contentlora.com.