Explainer
Why scientific papers are retracted
Retraction Watch counts an article as retracted when it has been removed from publication, temporarily or permanently, while a correction changes an article without removing it; under ICMJE guidance a retracted article stays available but is clearly labelled.[1][2] Journals retract for honest errors serious enough to invalidate the results as well as for misconduct, and a 2012 study of 2,047 retracted biomedical papers found 67.4% were retracted for misconduct and 21.3% for error.[3][4][5] The Retraction Watch database was acquired by Crossref in 2023 and made a public resource; at the time it held about 43,000 retractions.[6]
What a retraction is
Retraction Watch, which runs a public database of retractions, counts an article as retracted if it has been removed from publication, temporarily or permanently, whatever term the publisher uses. Corrections, by contrast, change an article without removing it.[1] Between the two sits the expression of concern: an editorial note, usually written by an editor, flagging doubts about an article’s integrity. The editor is responsible for investigating, and the outcome may require a retraction.[7]
Retracted papers do not disappear. The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) says they should stay publicly available but be clearly labelled as retracted, and that the retraction notice should explain why.[2]
Why papers are retracted
Honest error. The ICMJE says errors serious enough to invalidate a paper’s results and conclusions may require retraction. Where an honest mistake, such as a miscalculation, changes the conclusions, a journal can retract the paper and republish a corrected version.[3] The US National Library of Medicine (NLM) says articles are retracted because of pervasive error or unsubstantiated or irreproducible data.[8]
Misconduct. The US Office of Research Integrity defines research misconduct as fabrication, falsification or plagiarism, and excludes honest error and differences of opinion.[9] Under ICMJE guidance, if an institutional investigation proves misconduct, the editor should publish a retraction.[4]
The NLM does not distinguish in PubMed between papers retracted for honest error and those retracted for misconduct, so a retraction listed in PubMed does not by itself indicate intent.[8]
How often misconduct is the cause
A study published in PNAS in 2012 reviewed all 2,047 biomedical and life-science articles that PubMed listed as retracted on 3 May 2012. It found that 21.3% were retracted for error and 67.4% for misconduct: fraud or suspected fraud (43.4%), duplicate publication (14.2%) and plagiarism (9.8%).[5] The authors argued that incomplete or misleading retraction notices had led to fraud being underestimated, and that the share of articles retracted for fraud had risen about tenfold since 1975.[10]
Paper mills and mass retractions
Retraction Watch reported in December 2023 that Hindawi, a Wiley imprint, had retracted more than 8,000 articles that year, more than Retraction Watch had ever seen in a single year from all publishers combined, after paper mills infiltrated its special issues.[11] According to the same report, Wiley’s interim chief executive put the cost at an estimated $35-40 million in lost revenue, and Hindawi scored suspect papers against a checklist of manipulation indicators, retracting those above a threshold.[12]
The Retraction Watch database
Retraction Watch began as a blog in 2010. On 12 September 2023 Crossref acquired its database and made it a public resource. At the time it held about 43,000 retractions; with Crossref’s own records the combined total was around 50,000.[6] Crossref paid an initial fee of $175,000 and agreed to pay Retraction Watch $120,000 a year, rising 5% a year. The Center for Scientific Integrity and the Retraction Watch blog remain separate from Crossref.[13]
Both organizations frame retractions positively, describing them as an important part of science regulating itself and a sign that academic publishing is doing its job.[14] Retractions also feature in the wider reproducibility debate.
Checking a paper
- In PubMed, retraction notices and retracted articles are linked and labelled “Retraction of” and “Retraction in”.[15]
- The Retraction Watch database, now owned by Crossref, is a public resource.[6]
- Authors are responsible for making sure their reference lists do not cite retracted papers, except when discussing the retraction.[16]
How journals vet papers before publication is covered in how peer review works.
Read next
Next in the crash course
How US science is funded: NSF, NIH, DOE and indirect costs
Who pays for US research, how agencies such as NIH and NSF pick grants, what indirect costs are, and the 2025-26 fights over cuts, caps and terminations.
Questions readers ask
What does it mean when a paper is retracted?
The article is treated as removed from publication, temporarily or permanently. Under ICMJE guidance it stays publicly available but is clearly labelled as retracted, with a notice explaining why.[1][2]
Does a retraction mean the authors cheated?
Not necessarily. Journals also retract for honest errors serious enough to invalidate the results, and the US National Library of Medicine does not distinguish honest error from misconduct in PubMed.[3][8]
How common is misconduct among retractions?
A 2012 PNAS study of 2,047 retracted biomedical and life-science papers found 67.4% were retracted for misconduct, including fraud or suspected fraud (43.4%), duplicate publication (14.2%) and plagiarism (9.8%), and 21.3% for error.[5]
What is an expression of concern?
An editorial note, usually written by an editor, flagging doubts about an article's integrity. The editor is responsible for starting an investigation and reporting its outcome, which may require a retraction.[7]
Sources
· 16 claims from 6 publishers
Each numbered claim is a statement we checked against the sources listed with it. Tap a number in the text to see its sources in place.
- [1]
Retraction Watch treats any article removed from publication, temporarily or permanently, as retracted, whatever term the publisher uses, while corrections change an article without removing it. reportedas of 2026-11-08
- Retraction Watch Database User Guide · Retraction Watch · Secondary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Retraction Watch Database User Guide · Retraction Watch · Secondary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [2]
The ICMJE says retracted articles should stay publicly available but be clearly labelled as retracted, and the retraction notice should explain why. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals · International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals · International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [3]
The ICMJE says errors serious enough to invalidate a paper's results may require retraction, and honest errors that change the conclusions can be handled by retraction and republication of a corrected paper. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals · International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals · International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [4]
Under ICMJE guidance, if an institutional investigation proves scientific misconduct the editor should publish a retraction. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals · International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [5]
A 2012 PNAS study of 2,047 retracted biomedical and life-science articles in PubMed found 21.3% were retracted for error and 67.4% for misconduct, including fraud or suspected fraud (43.4%), duplicate publication (14.2%) and plagiarism (9.8%). confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications (Fang, Steen and Casadevall, PNAS 2012): abstract · PNAS (abstract via NCBI PubMed) · Primary source · 2012-10-16 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications (Fang, Steen and Casadevall, PNAS 2012): abstract · PNAS (abstract via NCBI PubMed) · Primary source · 2012-10-16 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [6]
On 12 September 2023 Crossref acquired the Retraction Watch database and made it a public resource; at the time it held about 43,000 retractions, and with Crossref's own records the combined total was around 50,000. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- News: Crossref and Retraction Watch · Crossref · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- News: Crossref and Retraction Watch · Crossref · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [7]
An expression of concern is an editorial note, usually by an editor, flagging doubts about an article's integrity; the editor is responsible for starting an investigation and reporting its outcome, which may require a retraction. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed · US National Library of Medicine · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed · US National Library of Medicine · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed · US National Library of Medicine · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [8]
The US National Library of Medicine says journals retract articles because of pervasive error or unsubstantiated or irreproducible data, and PubMed does not distinguish honest error from misconduct. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed · US National Library of Medicine · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed · US National Library of Medicine · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [9]
The US Office of Research Integrity defines research misconduct as fabrication, falsification or plagiarism, and excludes honest error and differences of opinion. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Definition of Research Misconduct · Office of Research Integrity (HHS) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Definition of Research Misconduct · Office of Research Integrity (HHS) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [10]
The 2012 study said incomplete or misleading retraction notices had led to underestimates of fraud, and that the share of articles retracted for fraud had risen about tenfold since 1975. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications (Fang, Steen and Casadevall, PNAS 2012): abstract · PNAS (abstract via NCBI PubMed) · Primary source · 2012-10-16 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications (Fang, Steen and Casadevall, PNAS 2012): abstract · PNAS (abstract via NCBI PubMed) · Primary source · 2012-10-16 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [11]
Retraction Watch reported in December 2023 that Wiley's Hindawi imprint had retracted more than 8,000 articles that year, more than Retraction Watch had ever seen in a single year from all publishers combined, after paper mills infiltrated its special issues. reportedas of 2023-12-19
- Hindawi reveals process for retracting more than 8,000 paper mill articles · Retraction Watch · Secondary source · 2023-12-19 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Hindawi reveals process for retracting more than 8,000 paper mill articles · Retraction Watch · Secondary source · 2023-12-19 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [12]
According to Retraction Watch, Wiley's interim chief executive put the cost of Hindawi's paper-mill problem at an estimated $35-40 million in lost revenue, and Hindawi scored suspect papers against a checklist of manipulation indicators, retracting those above a threshold. reportedas of 2023-12-19
- Hindawi reveals process for retracting more than 8,000 paper mill articles · Retraction Watch · Secondary source · 2023-12-19 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- Hindawi reveals process for retracting more than 8,000 paper mill articles · Retraction Watch · Secondary source · 2023-12-19 (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [13]
Crossref paid an initial fee of $175,000 and agreed to pay Retraction Watch $120,000 a year, rising 5% a year; the Center for Scientific Integrity and the Retraction Watch blog, founded in 2010, remain separate from Crossref. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- News: Crossref and Retraction Watch · Crossref · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- News: Crossref and Retraction Watch · Crossref · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- News: Crossref and Retraction Watch · Crossref · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [14]
Crossref and Retraction Watch describe retractions as an important part of science regulating itself and a sign that academic publishing is doing its job. confirmedas of 2026-11-08· interpretation
- News: Crossref and Retraction Watch · Crossref · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [15]
PubMed links retraction notices and retracted articles, labelling them "Retraction of" and "Retraction in" respectively. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed · US National Library of Medicine · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
- [16]
The ICMJE makes authors responsible for checking that their references do not cite retracted articles except when discussing the retraction. confirmedas of 2026-11-08
- Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals · International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) · Primary source (retrieved 2026-11-08)
Revision history (1)
- Page created.
Created Nov 8, 2026. Last reviewed by an editor on Nov 8, 2026. Next scheduled review: May 8, 2027.
Cite this page
"Why scientific papers are retracted." ContentLora, updated Nov 8, 2026. https://contentlora.com/explain/scientific-retractions-explained
Spotted an error? Suggest a correction or emailcorrections@contentlora.com.